| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revisionNext revision | Previous revisionLast revisionBoth sides next revision |
| articles:a_matter_of_risk [2022/06/12 15:14] – [A Matter of "Risk"] rrandall | articles:a_matter_of_risk [2023/01/31 13:47] – [The ISO 9001:2015 Conundrum] rrandall |
|---|
| |
| <note> | <note> |
| The ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1:2019 edition was restructured to (1) rename "Annex SL" to "Annex L" and (2) expand the scope of Annex L to include IEC management system standards (many of whom had been and remain, resistant to adopting the new structure and/or common content). However, the 2022 version has returned to "Annex SL" and no longer includes IEC. It now states: \\ | The ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1:2019 edition was restructured to (1) rename "Annex SL" to "Annex L" and (2) expand the scope of Annex L to include IEC management system standards (who was resistant to adopting the new structure and/or common content). However, the 2022 version has returned to "Annex SL" and no longer includes IEC (S-prefixed annexes only apply to ISO standards, while those without the prefix apply to both ISO and IEC standards). It now states: \\ |
| **SL.5 Applicability of this annex** \\ | **SL.5 Applicability of this annex** \\ |
| //The procedures in this annex apply to all ISO documents, including TS, PAS and IWA.// | //The procedures in this annex apply to all ISO documents, including TS, PAS and IWA.// |
| Note 4 to entry: Risk is often expressed in terms of a combination of the consequences of an event (including changes in circumstances) and the associated “likelihood” (as defined in ISO Guide 73) of occurrence.</blockquote> | Note 4 to entry: Risk is often expressed in terms of a combination of the consequences of an event (including changes in circumstances) and the associated “likelihood” (as defined in ISO Guide 73) of occurrence.</blockquote> |
| |
| <note>While the [[https://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/fetch/-8921878/8921901/16347356/16347818/2021-05_Annex_SL_Appendix_2.pdf?nodeid=21826538&vernum=-2|ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL]]:2022 is titled "Harmonized approach for management system standards" (HA), this is essentially the same as the previous “//High level structure//” (HLS). Interestingly, the actual ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL, Appendix 2]]:2022 is titled "//Harmonized structure for MSS with guidance for use//" (or "HS"). The differences in "ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL, Appendix 2" compared to ISO 9001:2015 are minimal. These differences are described at the end of an article titled [[https://www.quality.org/knowledge/high-level-structure-dead-long-life-harmonised-approach|"The High Level Structure is dead. Long life to the Harmonised Approach?"]].</note> | <note>While the [[https://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/fetch/-8921878/8921901/16347356/16347818/2022-05_Annex_SL_Appendix_2.pdf?nodeid=21826538&vernum=-2|ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL]]:2022 is titled "Harmonized approach for management system standards" (HA), this is essentially the same as the previous “//High level structure//” (HLS). Interestingly, the actual ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL, Appendix 2]]:2022 is titled "//Harmonized structure for MSS with guidance for use//" (or "HS"). The differences in "ISO/IEC Directives-Part 1, Annex SL, Appendix 2" compared to ISO 9001:2015 are minimal. These differences are described at the end of an article titled [[https://www.quality.org/knowledge/high-level-structure-dead-long-life-harmonised-approach|"The High Level Structure is dead. Long life to the Harmonised Approach?"]].</note> |
| |
| |
| Consequently, this has created a conundrum for users over how to properly address "risk". | Consequently, this has created a conundrum for users over how to properly address "risk". |
| |
| <note tip>To use an analogy, the online dictionary "[[https://www.wordnik.com/|Wordnik]]" includes two definitions for the word [[https://www.wordnik.com/words/day|"day"]]: \\ | <WRAP center round info 60%> |
| | To use an analogy, the online dictionary "[[https://www.wordnik.com/|Wordnik]]" includes two definitions for the word [[https://www.wordnik.com/words/day|"day"]]: \\ |
| n. The period of light between dawn and nightfall; the interval from sunrise to sunset. \\ | n. The period of light between dawn and nightfall; the interval from sunrise to sunset. \\ |
| n. The 24-hour period during which the earth completes one rotation on its axis, traditionally measured from midnight to midnight. \\ | n. The 24-hour period during which the earth completes one rotation on its axis, traditionally measured from midnight to midnight. \\ |
| \\ | \\ |
| Using this analogy, ISO //defines// "risk" as being both "negative" and "positive" in much the same way as a "day" can be interpreted as including both "light" and "darkness". However, the term "risks and opportunities" are used repeatedly in standards such as ISO 9001 & ISO 17025 in much the same way that one might casually refer to "day" and "night" as both occurring during a 24-hour "day".</note> | Using this analogy, ISO //defines// "risk" as being both "negative" and "positive" in much the same way as a "day" can be interpreted as including both "light" and "darkness". However, the term "risks and opportunities" are used repeatedly in standards such as ISO 9001 & ISO 17025 in much the same way that one might casually refer to "day" and "night" as both occurring during a 24-hour "day". |
| | </WRAP> |
| ==== Is the use of "Preventive Action" still valid? ==== | ==== Is the use of "Preventive Action" still valid? ==== |
| |
